a blog about things.

3.01.2010

The Pretentious Bootlegger

(the creative writing half hour of power. my important games article will be updated hopefully within the week. thank you for your cooperation~)

Day by day, Roger had never even thought about the possibilities that awaited every day when he went to work. He stood behind the counter, serving coffee and light food to any customer who waltzed in off the streets. Mostly, it was police officers; in uniform or out of it, it didn't matter, they seemed to flock to this little cafe with regularity. Two men whom Roger had come to recognize quite easily, Detective Shrinker and his right hand man, Ogilvy. They would always walk casually through the door at around 3 PM and come right to the counter, order two large cups of the house roast, black, and go sit in the booth by the left corner. Ogilvy, on occasions, would order a slice of pie to go with this coffee, Detective Shrinker never got anything other than his large black. They were both intimidating men, Shrinker especially; he was taller than Roger by about three inches, had dark brown eyes and a square jawline. His face was always decorated with light stubble.

Ogilvy's intimidation factor came from his incredibly weaselly looks. He was short and thin with unkempt hair and beady blue eyes. He looked like he was ready to do absolutely anything at any time; an unattended live wire. Shrinker had once told Roger that "yes, he is a bit eccentric...but he understands things that no one else does."

Roger got to the cafe around 12 AM for his shift, coming in out of the rain. It was a calming rain, that gentle rain that predates the coming of summer. The radio weatherman had mentioned that the rainy weather would stick around all day and evening, possibly clearing up later that night. He hung his leather coat in the staffroom and took a minute in the bathroom to clean his face and comb his hair properly. He'd awoken late and was in a rush that morning.

As he walked out and took his spot behind the counter, putting a fresh pot of coffee on, he saw that at that moment, not a single customer was in the store. He poured the last of the older pot into a cup for himself, throwing a bit of sugar and a dash of cream into it, stirring it with a spoon. He took a sip and turned to the kitchen.

"How are the sweets coming along, Mike? And where's Shauna?"

A few seconds of silence followed before a voice resounded back from the kitchen area.

"I'll be out with them in a few minutes, man. Make sure the display's cleaned out so I actually got room for 'em today. Uh, Shauna stepped out for a few. Said she was gonna go down the street and grab a magazine while the store was dead. Figured if anyone came in, I could take care of 'em."

"Alright."

Roger opened up the back of the glass display case next to the cash register. It was relatively clean already, just a few old pieces of paper for the sweets and goodies to rest on. He grabbed them, crumpled them into a bunch and tossed them into a nearby garbage can. He laid out fresh paper in all the spots as the door opened, ringing the bell attached to it.

An average looking girl wearing a short jean skirt and a white top walked in, holding an umbrella in her left hand and a plastic bag in the other. She smiled as Roger peaked up from behind the counter, putting her bag on the ground and pulling out a magazine and a small bottle of Pepsi.

"Hey, you're here, eh? Not like it matters, there still aren't any customers. Weird, isn't it?" she said to Roger, who nodded as Mike came from the kitchen holding a tray of baked goods. As the female walked behind the counter, he placed her drink and magazine near the register and folded her umbrella up, putting it in the staff room. She tied her long brown hair back into a ponytail and joined the other two in bringing the baked goods out of the kitchen, helping Roger with putting them in the display. The whole ordeal took a few minutes, after which the three stood and talked.

"So Shauna...I was wondering if I could get a few days the end of next week off. It's actually kind of important." Roger posed the question with absolute care. Shauna was, despite her niceness, a rather strict employer. She looked at him for a second, then put her head down and tapped her foot rhythmically on the floor.

"What days?"

"Just Saturday and Sunday. My family's having a little get together with my new brother in law's family. My sister joked that she'd kill me if I didn't show, though I don't think it was much of a joke." Shauna looked up at him again and eyed him inquisitively. She grinned.

"You're actually telling the truth, aren't you? Most of the time either of you two ask for time off, you're making it up...I'll be able to find someone to fill in for you, yeah. Don't worry about it."

On Tuesdays, it was usually like this. Not many customers, especially early in the morning. Around 1, some people, mostly cops, would come in and order some coffee, sit around for about a half hour and then get back to their patrols. Tuesday had one regular customer, a man named Tim Brown who worked across the street at a small jewelry shop. He would come over, wearing the same brown suit each day (Roger had once guessed he owned five pairs of the same suit) and order two things; a medium cup of the house roast with some cream and a chocolate Danish. He'd sit down, eat the Danish and drink the coffee in about ten minutes; never chatting with any of the employees at the counter while he made his order and disappear as fast as he'd came in.

Around 1:30, the door opened and that familiar brown suit walked in, today holding a brown leather suitcase in his left hand. He adjusted his glasses with his free hand and walked up to the counter.

"Oh, hey. Same as usual today?" Roger asked.

"Uh, no thanks. Not today, I'm actually in the mood for something a bit different." Roger was a bit stunned. After a few seconds, Tim spoke again.

"Same coffee, please. I'm kind of tired of the Danish, though. Let me take a quick look, alright? Thanks."

Tim started scanning the sweets display, looking for something that would catch his eye. After around a half minute of deliberation, he decided that he'd go with a slice of apple pie today. He fetched some money out of his wallet, paid for his two items, received them and sat in his usual spot. That was the most Roger had ever heard the man speak at one time.

Ten minutes later, Tim got up and wiped at his face with a napkin. He brought his cup and plate up to the counter, unusual behavior for himself. He placed them near the register and also threw a few dollars down as a tip for the staff. He smiled at Roger.

"That's real damn good pie, kid. Tell your baker that I'm impressed." Roger was a bit too dumbfounded to respond back properly, so he just nodded his head and smiled back at Tim. Tim went back to his spot for a second, grabbed the briefcase and walked out the door. Already, this was becoming a day that was firmly out of the ordinary. It was to get stranger.

Tuesdays were the only weekday were the pair of Shrinker and Ogilvy did not show. None of the staff could surmise why that would be, but never did the duo appear on a Tuesday.

At a few minutes after 3 PM, Ogilvy walked in through the door, wearing a cream colored sweater and a baseball cap. His shoes were caked in mud. He came up to the counter.

"Hey kid. Uh, tell me...you ain't seen my buddy around here, eh? You know who I mean, right?" he asked Roger, with some nervousness pervading his voice. He swallowed heavily as he waited for the answer.

"No, I haven't. I never see either of you two on Tuesdays, ever. What's the matter?"

"Oh...uh, nothing. Just wondering. We're actually both off duty on Tuesdays, but we were agreeing to meet today, here. Just like usual, really. Can I get my usual?" Ogilvy's eyes were darting around as he spoke to Roger. He seemed more high strung than usual. He paid for his items and took his spot in the left corner, sipping his coffee quietly and only eying his slice of pie.

Quarter after, Roger remembers it well, he happened to be glancing at the clock when Detective Shrinker walked in through the door. He looked like he always did, large and powerful. His stubble was present and he was dressed in his usual fare. His shoes, too, were caked in mud. Had the rain picked up outside? Roger wanted to ask, but Shrinker didn't come to the counter, he only went to the corner and sat down with his partner. He was staring across the booth's table at him. Ogilvy, however, was still eying the slice of pie he had bought. Shrinker's voice was hushed as he spoke, and Ogilvy responded in kind. Roger couldn't make out their conversation.

They were there quite a while. It was almost 4 PM when finally Shrinker took the pie, ate it himself, and the two stood up. They left, unceremoniously. Roger felt a strange surrealism in the air, like none of this had ever happened. Or if it did, it happened in some strange alternate dimension. The next three hours were just a hazy, undirected dream. Roger left at 7, grabbing his coat from the staff room and bidding farewell to Julie, who'd came in around 6 to run the store's night shift. Shauna and Mike had already gone, although Roger couldn't quite piece together when. Everything since that slice of pie disappeared, courtesy of Detective Shrinker had made little objective sense. It was...it was too strange.

Oddly enough, it had stopped raining.

2.16.2010

The Ten Most Important Games of the Last Decade (Part I)

So, if it hasn't been made painfully obvious for you as of yet, it's the year 2010. It has been said year for about two and a half boring months (by my experience, perhaps you're having a blast). Now that it's 2010, what do we have to think about? For me, there's largely nothing. However, the past decade was a decade I spent firmly rooted as a player of video games. That's kind of important to me. Now, looking back on that decade, I'm aiming to compile a list of the truly important games of the last ten years.

Before we get going, let's broaden that definition a little bit, regarding what it means when I call a game "important". This is not a measure of quality or of creativity, although it can be. It really depends. For the record, let's be frank in saying that my opinion doesn't mean a whole lot. It certainly doesn't command a lot of leverage, that's for sure. So, for a game to be important, what kind of criteria are we looking for? I'm going to summarize it as basically being a measure of what the game has or can do for the industry, likely by breaking the mold and introducing something fresh. A terrible game can, at times, inspire a plethora of things and change the way we perceive the gaming collective.

Let's not waste a whole lot of time right now (there will likely be plenty of time for those sort of antics later). My plan, right now, is to finish this list in its entirety in about a month's time. The choices are going to be well thought out or completely not thought out at all. It's my list, I'll do as I please. And don't be upset if I left your favorite game off the list. Chances are, I don't feel the same way about it. If I do, that's wonderful! I'm always looking for people with good opinions. Hell, if they're good enough, you could probably contribute to this blog (I'm being 100% serious here! Wanna write about video games? Send me an email (lowepat @ gmail.com) with your interest and perhaps a small sample. Please do not have wonderful labels such as GRAPHICS or SOUND in your review, that's a sign you're trying too hard. Just write. Make sure to be unique, too.).

in NO particular order

Katamari Damacy (PlayStation 2, 2004, Namco)

I've managed to throw more mentions towards this game in previous reviews than was likely necessary. This game gets mentioned a ton by me because I'm absolutely in love with it. Where do we even start?

Katamari Damacy is basically, in a lot of ways, god damned super 3D Pacman. Its goals are obvious and its style of play is simple as could be. Everything about this game has a TON of style, which is where it truly excels. There are detractors who claim that it is "too short, too repetitive", all I really have to say to these people is that they are pretty much stupid. These are the same people who fellate the hell out of the big RPG experiences, in which you do the same thing for about forty hours and watch as the numbers go up so other numbers can go down. Something that long must have a lot of depth, or most definitely has the ability to pretend to have it.

What do we do in Katamari Damacy? It's pretty great to be able to say that never once while playing the game is it necessary to use our imagination. The game is far too busy doing that for us, and for once, it's for the better.  Keita Takahashi's influences on the game are, for the most part, visual artists. A notable one is Tadao Ando, a Japanese architect who has designed some absolutely beautiful, perplexing buildings and sites. Go onto your GIS (Google Image Search for the unenlightened half-wits out there) and look up "Rokko Housing" to get a glimpse at some of his designs. Takahashi seems to have a bit of interest in the field as well, he's repeatedly been quoted as wanting to design a children's playground. Katamari Damacy is a playground, that's for sure.

There's not a whole lot going on in Katamari Damacy. Its idea is that your objective in each level (with some slight variations not really worth mentioning) is for your Katamari (a ball with the ability to snag up essentially anything and everything) to reach a certain size. To do this, we roll the ball around. As we hit objects, they may attach to us. Or we might be too small, as of yet, to grab the object and we are deflected. In that instant, we realize the issue and we go roll up more smaller objects. Eventually, we come back to that larger object and absorb it into the mishmash of items that our Katamari has snatched up. We keep going, and hopefully before our limited time has depleted, we are of the right size or bigger.

The fun thing about the game is that there is always this sense of tension, especially in the later levels where the size we're required to get seems out of our reach from the very beginning. You play, rolling up plenty of objects and increasing in size with somewhat of a steady pace, but you're still not that close. You're accessing new areas of the level due to your Katamari's size, but there's just not a lot you seem to picking up. Suddenly, you start gaining huge increases in the radius of the ball, seemingly out of nowhere. You just barely make the grade (maybe with twenty or so seconds to spare). This seems to happen a lot, until you get really good at memorizing a level's layout and knowing the greatest payoff spots for size. In a very matter of fact sense, Katamari Damacy is getting bigger and bigger by the second.

Something that always struck me about the game, something I took the time to remember, is that at any moment you want, you can pause the game and be given a comparison for your size. It is randomized, picking an item out of the hundreds, if not thousands of items in the game and telling you: "Your Katamari is the size of 2434101024 Telephones!". That, right there, is a lot of fucking telephones. 

And really, what's more important in life than telephones? Who doesn't have a cellular phone? (I don't =3) Everywhere I go, people are on the phone. It's hard being a social outcast (lol), what with the no phone and all! Maybe that's what growing up is all about, getting a phone that you can never ever have an excuse for not having, and be expected to be in touch with everyone at all times.

Katamari Damacy is a very gutsy game. It is no bullshit, and it's not "style over substance" as I've heard it referenced before. It has the right amount of substance and the right amount of style to act companion to that substance.

The Sims (PC, 2000, Electronic Arts)

Now I'm going to be incredibly forward here and preface the following paragraphs with the fact that I dislike the Sims. Honestly, I never ever got into the craze. Maybe I was too young to understand my sister's fascination in the series, or maybe I was (and still am) too childish to do anything other than kill my "sims" in increasingly complicated ways. Mostly, I just threw three or four of the fuckers into a house, removed the doors, filled it with wooden furniture, and set it ablaze. Not often did I go past that mark on the creativity scale, but the important thing is that I was, for some perverse reason, enjoying myself.

Maybe I'd enjoy the Sims, now. Of course, when a game is successful, especially when it's that successful (who hasn't heard of the Sims, honestly) we will get the sequel treatment. In an effort of businessmen wanting to make more money, to sail more yachts and buy more gorgeous women to accompany them, women who don't care about your bald spot or your doughy physique when you have enough money; the aforementioned decided it was a great idea to make "expansions" to the Sims formula, piece by piece. People bought the expansions without really realizing that they were wasting their precious, hard earned money, and so the people of Maxis and Electronic Arts got richer and richer.  This happens in games! Look at Street Fighter II, which had incremental expansions released for what felt like forever, and by the time Street Fighter 3rd Strike came out, everyone still preferred the second game.

What makes me think I might actually have fun with the Sims now? I've come to understand, and like a lot of things I never did previously in the last few years. Thanks to the creation of Coke Zero, I will now drink Coke products quite willingly. I still prefer Pepsi, but I will drink Coke. That is just one of the many inconsequential maturations that I've undergone. The older you get, the more you realize that you are incapable of living an entire life without doing things that you don't want to do. So maybe I can play the Sims now, that's what I tell myself.

Now, you might be thinking at this point that this decision was based primarily on "popularity". You'd be wrong, partially. The game's popularity is an immense point towards why it gets on this list, but I am in no way biased towards the game because of that. I actually had to do some hard thinking to come to this choice! Without the Sims, we might be living in a world where people actually give a damn about their own lives.  I'm sure there are plenty of people who do, yeah. Let's analyze that for just a moment.

The Sims is escapism. You play the role of an "overseer" for a character, or perhaps a family of characters. You make all their decisions, what to watch on TV, what kind of things to have in the house, when to take a piss or have a shower. You are the "god" of the world, except that you're able to lose the game. Your characters can become unhappy, sickly, and may wind up dead because their lives are just too damn terrible.  You start another family, and decide to theme their house a specific way. There was (probably still is) a bustling mod community for the Sims where people designed custom appearances for objects so as to let you make your "dream house". You give these people everything you want in life, and then you realize:

"OH fuck, I haven't showered in two days. The garbage needs to be taken out. I haven't eaten in probably close to twelve hours, and I'm out of ramen noodles and oven pizza. My job called yesterday and they said if I take another sick day, I'm fired. Hey, Dmitri seems unhappy..."

And you're back to playing the game because you've fallen into that simple trap. The objectives of the Sims, the needs of its characters are so almost identical to that of our own that when we play, we can't escape the game. The Sims probably ruined a life or two here and there, which is scary and a little bit captivating if you're like me.

The notable thing about the Sims, other than ruining the lives of people who were probably running a near autonomous lifestyle anyways, is that the game is not only more fun, but incredibly more rewarding when you cheat. Starting off, you'll notice two things about the game; you don't have near enough money to furnish a house with "good" furniture (a bad bed = bad sleep) and that you don't have enough time to do fucking anything. It's pretty inane how you tell your Sim to go to the bathroom and about an hour later, they accomplish it. No wonder he can never get to work on time, and when he does he's too cranky because he can't sleep! So you put it in a cheat code or two, get a bunch of money, and spend, spend, spend. Get all the best stuff. Make even having a job for the poor character completely extraneous. That's it, you've beat the game. Now, just play.

The Sims is a milestone, really. Nowadays, we see the influences of the simulation genre burgeoning into others, taking up residence on the proverbial doorsteps of video games everywhere. More importantly, it's escapism that works by drawing on real life. Caring for virtual humans is easy, as long as you've an idea how to care for yourself.

World of Warcraft (PC, 2004, Blizzard Entertainment)

This is frankly the choice of this list that I disagree the most with, personally. I've never actually sat down and played this game. I frankly have nil interest in the game.

Yet, it may be the most prominent piece of entertainment that emerged in the last decade, the entire entertainment industry included. So many men and women play this game on a daily basis, around eleven and a half million monthly subscriptions exist at the present time for this game. That's what we in the business (and we outside it too!) call a god damned phenomena. 

World of Warcraft is a job. I've never been able to see it as anything else. Millions of individuals, many whom could be doing any number of important things and contributing to society, are spending their time fighting monsters and doing quests so that they can gain levels, get new equipment, and get better. This isn't like a sport, though. All this repetition does is reinforce the fact that these people are paying good money to do the same damn thing, over and over again.

Let's be frank. I've never been exactly what I'd call a social person. I have a lot of little things that bug me, and a lot of people possess these little "things", so naturally I'm not a good people person. The concerns of the players of World of Warcraft are such things as "forming parties" and "finishing quests".

FUCK THAT NOISE.

Honestly. That's depraved. That's saddening. Let's get this into easy terms that we can all understand. When I "form a party", I'm getting together with a group of living, breathing humans. When I "finish a quest", I'm accomplishing something that I enjoy or think will be a means of personal betterment (let's use lifting weights as an example). These terms are as cut and dry as they sound in the actual World of Warcraft universe. Groups of people, who are real people in the sense that behind every character is an actual human player, gather so that they may tackle the dangers of the world and get ever closer to "finishing a quest". It's a novel concept, I'll give it that. What do you get for that quest?

Well, you're certainly going to get some numbers going up. The RPG genre, whether Western, Japanese, or MMO is obsessed with numbers, like some obsessive compulsive mathematician. In an RPG, your goal at the most basic of premises is to make sure your numbers stay up and find ways to make the numbers of your enemy go down. So, naturally; your reward in these games is the same as your goal, and that is to have high numbers regarding your character(s). All this number shit actually makes it look like something really important is going down, and that's where the illusion of depth comes into play.

There's not a whole lot wrong with tricking us, the player, into seeing depth where there is none. World of Warcraft pulls a double whammy, not only is there plenty of depth, there's social interaction (in a sense).  This is all incredibly key. To keep people together, Blizzard has designed many parts of the game to be accessible and completable only by groups. These groups will spend hours (no exaggeration) skulking through some dingy shithole of a dungeon, fighting enemies, gaining experience, fighting bigger enemies, gaining more experience...this is what these people do.

Eventually, you might start to think that you should be getting paid for this, instead of paying for it. Hell, we're pretty certain at this point that Blizzard makes enough money to throw a little chump change at the player and not start cutting names off the payroll. Like mentioned, World of Warcraft is a job. It's rearranging the cells of a Microsoft Excel document into the right order. It's making sure the bar graphs on the latest company earnings are big and important, that the spreadsheets will come up in the proper order so as to avoid looking like a complete fool. Remember that day when your boss asked you to come in four hours early, so that you could look through mountains of unorganized paper for something he had in his god damn office desk? 

Let's be completely hypothetical here. Let's say that tomorrow, Blizzard had to shut down. With it, the World of Warcraft servers are forced permanently offline. You now have ten million people who have to replace that time with something else. Some of them may move to other games. (sidenote: there are people who play inferior versions of World of Warcraft and the like because they're freeware. they don't feel like paying the money to play the real thing, so they play a cheap knock off instead because they've got to get their fix.) Some of them may focus on their actual job and get promoted. Some of them, because this game meant the world to them (and there are definitely people like this in the world) may go out in the streets and just kill someone. I'm not saying this happens! I reckon though, taking this game away from its die-hard enthusiasts would be like convincing a coke addict to quit cold turkey. There's going to be a lot of mental instability.

People have told me that they made a decision to "quit" this game. That's what I find the most telling. If I'm playing a video game, let's say...let's say I'm playing Super Mario Brothers 3. I'll use this as an example because I love it. I play until I get until about the sixth world and then I happen upon some bad luck and get a game over. I stop playing.

I have not quit Super Mario Brothers 3. I simply don't want to play at this moment. I was having a ton of fun and then I happened to lose. World of Warcraft, you don't lose. You just stop playing, whether it's for ten minutes, three days, two months, or forever. When you stop playing it forever, you have quit. Like leaving a job, you have a sudden realization that you were just doing it because you had to. You needed the money. Or in the case of World of Warcraft, you needed an outlet. You needed something to do with your mounds of free time and your hard earned dollars that felt rewarding. We've already outlined that the rewards are as fake as some supermodel's body (which probably cost more than your car!). So, you've quit World of Warcraft and you lose that sense of accomplishment that you were doing something that felt like it mattered.

The world changed with World of Warcraft, for better or for worse. It could be worse though, it could be Second Life (maybe the worst "video game" ever made).

WINDING DOWN

I'd like to thank you for reading the first part of this article and would also like to assure you that the list will be updated within the next few weeks. As mentioned, there's a decent amount of thought and research being put into this. Alternatively, you can also read this article under the pretense that I'm putting no thought into it and pulling random names out of a hat! You're the reader, I leave the choices up to you.

2.04.2010

Cave Story (****)

A video game "review"

Doukutsu Monogatari (Cave Story) for the PC

developed by Studio Pixel

published by Studio Pixel

score: **** (Game of the Year 2004)

I've decided to wind the clock back about five years and write a review about a game that I enjoy. Being back to work full time, and out of school for a little while, I'm using my time to do all I've ever really wanted to do anyways, play video games. Hell, I figured that out when I was a lot younger, although I suspect I've been an adult for quite a while!

Cave Story is about as pure as the modern video game can strife to be. In an era where we are bombarded by bullshit from every direction from pretty much everything, it's like a dip in the cold pool on the warmest summer day to see something like Cave Story. Let's look a bit at the nature of the game and we'll quickly become aware of why it is what it is. In the time of huge, multi-million dollar productions, Cave Story was cobbled together by the efforts and free time of one man, Daisuke Amaya, the aforementioned Studio Pixel. Obviously, there's a lot of love that went into Cave Story. Its ideas aren't really new, just startlingly well executed.

Before we delve further (well, at all I guess) into this review, I'm going to take a few minutes of your time and talk about absolutely nothing. I'm notoriously good at talking about nothing, after all.

So, another year has gone and passed, without much incident to myself. A bit of a change in the plans of my "life" have led to me being out of school for a little while. I'm going to be going back in the fall, hopefully to start my way to procuring a Journalism degree. After that, I think I might move to Japan or something. To be drop dead serious for a minute, Canada is kind of boring. No offense, I do actually like where I live but man, is it ever boring. Why do you think it is that I play video games all the time? Gotta occupy myself somehow, and it seems to be the only way I'm coming up with (okay lifting weights and running, as well as working, whatever). So, my plan is to get out of Canada and move somewhere where I'm gonna be barely visible in the general population. Right now, my concerns are so tiny that I just can't bring myself to really care.

I was just checking my laundry in the designated room in my apartment building. Apparently, leaving my laundry unattended for an hour when the dry cycle takes forty five minutes is some sort of cardinal, loathing sin. Someone left me a note explaining how inconsiderate I was! Stuff like this, these small little bumps and concerns in life just feel so fake. Is this really what adulthood is about? Just shuffling through miniscule things like this?

Cave Story is a nice way to get away from growing old, a certain little piece of that friendly childhood nostalgia. Like I mentioned, it doesn't do a whole lot that is wholly original. Where its genius lies is in the care of how its elements are put together. Currently, I'm thoroughly upset with the video game scene for its treatment of sequels. Basically, instead of creating new, unique games and properties , the real way to make any money (which is all the developers really care about) is to make something popular and expand it beyond any reasonable limits. I mean, god, look at Mario. Isn't it about time that we get tired of Mario games? I know I am! I can reasonably assume that people are getting tired of me talking about Mario games too!

Let's stop painting in broad strokes and talk about the details regarding Cave Story being one of the greatest video games of all time. It's ambition was, as far as I can tell, to pay tribute to the games of old. Its design brings memories of Metroid and Megaman rushing into your brain, without being a blatant copy of either of them. We start Cave Story with a character attempting to make conversation with another through the use of instant messaging on a computer. We have no idea who this character is or who he's trying to get in touch with. Are we going to be this man at the computer?

We wake up, somewhere in the world. Surrounded by caves, we are unaware of who exactly we are. We have no weapon and we're most certainly alone. A really inquisitive person can figure out a few things about this first room in the game: how to use the save and healing points, and they can also decide, if they want to, to die in the first room. Anyways, you quickly figure out how to get out of the room (what game stumps a player in its first room? Either a very bad or very cruel one.) and you try to get a bearing on your surroundings. Maybe you try going right first and find that you can't proceed that way. Enemies and an unbreakable (at the moment) wall hinder your path. You go to the left, looking for a weapon. You might, if you're hasty, proceed down the first hill, hit a patch of spikes (which are blood red in color, to denote just how dangerous they can be) and die. Next time, you'll be more careful. Eventually, you weave through a path of spikes and enemies and you find a gun in another room. It's in a treasure box (one can never resist the allure of a treasure box). From here on out, Cave Story is yours to play.

One of the greatest nuances in Cave Story is how one goes about obtaining any one of the three endings. One is incredibly blatant, easy to obtain, and completely unsatisfying. I doubt many people get this ending when they play, simply because it is just as easy to avoid as it is to obtain. The second ending is the standard ending, complete with a great final boss fight and an ending to the story that seems conclusive. It's also quite challenging, in its own right. To obtain this ending, all you really have to do is follow what the game logically sets up for you. The real genius is that in order to obtain the real, and quite viciously difficult ending, you must understand the influences on this game, particularly its Metroid influence.

Let's talk about Metroid. Specifically, the very first Metroid game. Everyone always tends to talk about Super Metroid or the Prime series, so we're not going to. Metroid was this weird, notoriously obtuse game where in order to progress, you basically had to search every square inch of the screen and hope that something you were able to do would let you through. Mainly, you could bomb walls that looked no different from the walls you couldn't bomb. It was Metroid where it seemed like we can see the evolution of compulsive behavior in video games, the kind that persists even today. Take any of the Pokémon games, where the whole aim is to "catch them all". At first, that was one hundred fifty. Now, that number is in the four hundreds (sorry I don't know the exact number, I haven't played a Pokémon game in what seems like forever). Even after you catch them, you're presented with the next challenge, even more insurmountable, "can I make these Pokémon good in battle?". That's actually pretty brilliant game design. What would it be like if all you could do was collect the Pokémon? It's pretty doubtful that anyone would even want to play it. The battles are the real meat of the game!

In Cave Story, you have different weapons. Consider them the "pocket monsters" of the game. Chances are, your first time through the game, you won't collect them all. Actually, on a realistic note, it's impossible to obtain every weapon in Cave Story on the same playthrough. So there's always that, but even then; you may miss the opportunities to get certain weapons. Straightforward thinking will get you nowhere. Now, not only do you have a multitude of weapons, these weapons also have levels. You know what that means, right? If not, I'll explain it in a very matter of fact way. Kill an enemy, they drop triangular crystals of "experience", pick them up, pick up enough of them while holding a weapon and it will increase in level, thereby increasing in power. The opposite can also be true, getting hit by your enemies will drop your weapon experience (as well as your health). Pretty damn simple game mechanic, but really well done.

The weird thing is, to me, that you'll likely have some weapons you never really want to bother with. The very precise usefulness of several of the weapons will likely have you disregarding them, picking up the experience for your other weapons and using them instead. That's a pretty acceptable choice! We don't discredit you for sticking to the weapons you actually enjoy. Now, back to the Pokémon analogy I was making earlier, have you ever stopped to wonder why there are so many damn Pokémon? Half of them, I bet, get ignored by the general playing populace because they're useless. Having been a big fan of the games, I'll go ahead and confirm that assumption. People get together and play in tournaments, pitting their game monsters against each other. In these tournaments, the Legendary Pokémon are pretty much always banned because they're too good. They can learn too many good moves and coupled with their high stats, it makes them far too ready for any situation. So, people have learned ways to train the other monsters into being useful. The legendary monsters are basically just there to make the meta-game (think of it as the game after the game) easier. Pokémon games don't actually end in a traditional sense, you beat the final boss and you're given the option to just kind of keep playing forever, raising more monsters and trying to get ready to take on all challengers, which is pretty heroic sounding. Now, picture yourself as being an avid player. You've built up a team of six different monsters that you consider to be "pretty awesome". You engage another, actual real life human player in a battle (no doubt your first human contact in roughly six months time (this is a well constructed joke)) and they stomp your ass into the ground. What kind of lesson does that teach you? Likely nothing.

Cave Story is all about teaching a lesson. Going way back in this review, to where I was talking about Metroid and its definitive trait, I'm pretty sure that's the lesson that Cave Story is trying to tell us. Make sure that you take the time out of your busy schedule of trying to finish this game before your friends to actually look around. Make sure to leave no stone unturned, or else you're going to have to settle with the regular ending (which is still pretty good). It's a reinforcement of the one value a lot of people I know, a lot of people worldwide left behind when we became "adults": our curiosity.

You may be noticing that this review is lacking in the "wit" that I've displayed in my previous reviews. Don't worry, we'll be getting to the paragraphs constructed simply to force along painful one-liners and absurd generalizations. Let's talk about video games for a little while, you and I. There's been a lot of painful talk lately that the gaming industry in Japan is in trouble. I'm not really at liberty to say whether or not that's entirely true, but it seems to be the general consensus going around. Economically, it's not that hard to see why.

Keita Takahashi, a favorite developer of mine despite his criminally limited body of work (Katamari Damacy, Noby Noby Boy) has said of the medium: "...I believe videogames should always be a medium that everyone around the world can understand and enjoy. Forget the money side of things, games should just be pure fun and enjoyment." That, right there, is the attitude I wish was prevailing in the industry today. No wonder it's going downhill, every company is really just aiming for the same thing and that's making money. Hopefully millions of dollars, so that they can go on vacation, buy fancier cars, and keep making video games so that they can make more money. There are very few developers who can go against the grain and make exactly what they want. The modern day video game needs to do a few, key things to really appease the players:

  1. give the player the sense that they are always accomplishing something

  2. engage them, no matter what the situation

  3. be presentable (kind of like NOT going to a fancy business party dressed in faded jeans, circa the early '80s)

The gamer is literally obsessed with being rewarded at pretty much every juncture. Final Fantasy XIII, which is a good game but not a great one constantly gives the player a feeling of accomplishment with the ranking system employed in the battles. That is, until you figure out that the rankings are completely and utterly insignificant. Say for example, you get a five star ranking in one battle, and then in a battle with the exact same enemies, you get a two star rating for whatever reason. You will receive the same amount of Crystal Points (there is no experience in Final Fantasy XIII) regardless and the item drops, if they happen, will not be different, so why have the ranking system? Simply put, to make the gamer seem as if they're accomplishing something, plus it gives them some sort of weird aspiration to do better (I should know, I have played it). Five stars is obviously better than two! Final Fantasy XIII does the three listed objects incredibly well, during battles against who knows what (the design in the game is stellar in a very creative sense) you are very damn engaged because it is just impressively flashy. I mean god, is the game ever white hot.

So, what's the matter with being accessible to the average gamer? If you're trying to make money (we've laid the groundwork to see that that is absolutely the case) it's certainly not the wrong path to be taking, but we've also seen that in order to be truly accessible we must sacrifice a certain bit of creativity. Sometimes, the truly creative individual (Keita Takahashi, for example) will think something up where the appeal of the game is the creativity or abstract nature of the game itself. Katamari Damacy didn't become a damn near sensation because of its easy play mechanics, it was the culture behind it. It was a weird, inventive game based around the simple mechanic of "roll things up, get bigger, roll up bigger things". It was artistic. It was a modern art video game and it'll likely be appreciated for years to come. A recent game which has "rejected" accessibility is From Software's Demon Souls, a grandiose PS3 exclusive that might be a front runner for the "Best Video Game of 2009". It is at this point I draw attention to this review's illustrious score (****) and the following line of "Game of the Year 2004". So, back to Demon's Souls because talking about the video game you're actually reviewing is so cliché and I'm attempting to be as edgy and unlikable as possible!

Some people have said that Demon's Souls has no place in modern gaming because it is frequently an unrewarding, challenging catastrophe. You can and will die without much alarm and it is as unceremonious as possible because it becomes a common event. However, dying is simply a part of the game, so much that it is impossible to actually lose the game. The only way to lose to Demon's Souls is to stop playing it. You are actually being rewarded on a near constant basis in Demon's Souls, just the nature of those rewards can sometimes be too subtle to truly appreciate it. Learning where a certain enemy lurks and how it attacks, while still dying in the process is one such example. You can overcome that obstacle once you come to understand its nature. Eventually, you progress in a quantifiable amount and then you fucking die, again. It's a frustrating feeling, but you'll get used to it. You may finally amass enough souls (the game's universal currency, it is used for everything under the sun) to get a new weapon or upgrade an integral stat. This may or may not enable you to make a little more headway.

I believe personally that Demon's Souls is a game for everyone, because it's a more engaging experience than a lot of games out there and the character options are wide enough to give a variety of play styles, so it can encompass a lot of people's desires. 

So, back to Cave Story (collective reading audience: "Finally."). The point I've been trying to make about accessibility is that Cave Story understands what that means. To be truly open to the gaming populace, you must offer them the choice of how to play the game, their way. The multiple weapons operate in such vastly differing ways from other ones that a player can carve out a particular combat style. The truly curious gamer will pick up on the clever integrated mechanics that you go about to find the secrets and head to the perfect ending, which requires skill as well as cunning. At one point, you can either accept a jet pack from an NPC (who you're likely going to talk to) or make a difficult jump that is cleverly marked out by a strange mark on the ground which shows you when you need to jump in order to the clear the gap, totally ignoring the NPC. Get the jet pack, and the jump becomes simple. That decision alone will cost you the best ending. Is that fair? Absolutely, because the game is built in such a way that you're supposed to question it.

Japan and video games are nearly synonymous. There has been a major upswing in the presence of the Western developers later, coinciding with the "death of the Japanese games industry". Is there any real relation to this? We can look at the current tastes of the gamer and see that it may have some sort of relationship, yes. The success of the Modern Warfare games is namely the obsession with the first person shooter coming to a forefront and that's what people want to play. Largely, I think the big thing right now is playing games with others. MAG, just recently released, emphasizes its humongous player to map ratio (256 players on one map). However, this trend seems to be relatively limited to the market outside of Japan. People in Japan seem to be relatively secure with playing by themselves (there was really no working outside of that innuendo, was there?). The remake of Dragon Quest VI, the best selling game of 1995, was just released for the Nintendo DS console. In its first day, the Japanese bought roughly a million copies. Have I ever mentioned that the Dragon Quest games sell ridiculously in Japan? A little research shows that no numbered Dragon Quest games (parts of the main series) have sold under a million copies in their homeland of Japan. Every game that comes out, the numbers seem to go up. Hell, Dragon Quest IX for the Nintendo DS (the world's most popular console) has sold like 4 something million copies and it came out in July. It's not even out in North America yet. I mean, there's some sort of phenomena going on there.The Dragon Quest games, however, don't sell the greatest over in our half of the world, they never have and likely they probably never will. Blame it on the seclusive nature of the games, blame it on the formula that hasn't been updated much since the first game came out in 1986 and was referred to as being archaic even all the way back then.

So, what have we figured out about video games? That you can usually fit them into two molds, seclusive or what we'll call "friendly" games. Cave Story is a seclusive game, both in design and in atmosphere. You will spend some of the best hours of your life playing it.

Let's talk about something specific within Cave Story, actually. Since we've been spending the majority of the review talking about nothing, let's take time out of our busy schedule to talk about something. I'm sitting here missing some skin on my right hand (never rotate an analog stick with your palm at warp-speed) and I'm not really feeling the whole process right now. It hurts, seriously. 

=(

Add to the fact that it's almost three o'clock in the morning and I'm wide awake; which is probably the best possible time to do any writing of any sort...this is really sort of aggravating. So, Cave Story, yeah.

INTERMISSION

So, what exactly makes Cave Story the "Game of the Year, 2004"? That's a hefty title to bestow upon anything. As a note, I'm going by the initial release (and so far, only) of the game, which was December 2004 in Japan. The game hasn't gotten an American release yet, although I've heard rumors to watch the WiiWare channel on Nintendo's Wii console. Cave Story's independent translation by the grand group over at Aeon Genesis saw release in early 2005, so we're going to strictly regard Cave Story as a game of 2004. The game, actually.

What was I doing in the year 2004? Being nineteen years old now (what a boring time of life), I'd have been fourteen. Last year of junior high school, if I recall. Back when the only real thing I was capable of was being picked on (slight exaggeration). 2004 was a year where I couldn't have cared less about things. Definitely, at fourteen, I would not have invisioned my nineteen year old writing reviews like this. Cave Story is the realization of a great invisioning. Secrets have longed played humongous roles in video games.  

Used to be, that secrets were considered the norm for design. However, despite their secretive nature, many things you were forced to accomplish in games of old were the only means of getting ahead. Video game magazines were prospering back then, before the advent of video gaming websites where the answers were just a click away. Kids would buy, or maybe even steal these magazines just go get through that one dungeon in the original Legend of Zelda, or find all the secrets in Super Mario Bros. 3 (what a great game). Cave Story is such a great loveletter to that feeling.

Daisuke Amaya showed great ability in Cave Story. His artwork was unique and beautiful, he had an ear for music that led to some catchy tunes and great atmosphere, and his storytelling was simple, yet as bold as his art. Cave Story told us a simple story, but it did it well. The convoluted plots of the modern JRPG have rarely (if ever) been told this well. The plot of Cave Story is there to compell us through the game, probably nothing more. We can all assume that Amaya-kun was not trying to really send a message, or change our lives, simply; his game needed a story because why else would the player really bother? And if the story is well told, it is that much more appealing.

Ikachan, Amaya's first video game was released in the year 2000. The namesake character, Ikachan, is a friendly squid who tries to help his other aquatic friends. It is quaint, cute, and designed interestingly. Ikachan's controls, at the start of the game, forbid fully horizontal movement. A weird hindrance, that once you play the game, feels only natural. Some game developers give us far too much, the smartest ones will take enough away to make us truly appreciate what we have (once again, I'll shout to Keita Takahashi at this point, who should be reading this...seriously though anyone who can look at a PS2 controller, and devise awesome gameplay while ignoring every face button is a genius). Cave Story takes a lot away from us, and never once does it try to give it back. You cannot, for example, shoot diagonally. Every primary direction (downwards shots can only be done in the air, but still, they're doable and with one weapon can actually act as a slight hover) can be used for attacking, but you're not allowed to attack diagonally (which would be mighty useful and perhaps even a bit of a game-breaker. Hence why it's not there.). You can, however, fight what appears to be an anthropomorphic lunch-box/toaster. That is ten times more awesome than it sounds!

The best weapon in Cave Story is a special gun called the Nemesis. You can obtain it at only one area in the game, rather specifically, it's pretty much where you start the game. When you obtain your first weapon, you steal it from a sleeping weaponsmith. This area of the game becomes unaccessible for the longest time after you leave it. So long, in fact, that you might not even ever think of returning there. Suppose, perhaps, you do. The weaponsmith has awakened, and he's a bit peeved at your thievery. He chews you out, and you get your fingers ready to just flip the dude off, walk away, and perhaps fuck his wife (childish humor is what you readers want, eh?). Earlier in the game, you traded the Polar Star (the first gun) to another character for her machinegun, because you thought "damn would I want a machinegun" and then the game offered it to you. Hours ago, you made a mistake which would defy you the best weapon in the game.

Second time through, on your way to trying to get the best ending (which you should definitely have the Nemesis for) you decide to keep the Polar Star. You go back to the weaponsmith when the opportunity presents itself, and he chews you out. Again. Then he notices that you've put his weapon to extraordinarily good use. He is impressed, inspired. He says that he never actually finished the weapon, so he grabs it from you and completes it, granting you the Nemesis. In a game where levelling up the weapons you obtain to gain their true abilities is imperative, the Nemesis totally ignores that concept. Its levels are based on how long you hold the fire button (initially set as the X button on your keyboard). This enables you to switch its performance based on the situation. Need rapid-fire? Slam that button.

Cave Story is, like Demon's Souls, a game you only lose when you stop playing it. It is rewarding in ways you can't initially comprehend. It is more than just a satisfying experience. Ten to fifteen years ago, I remember when I first played Earthbound, for the SNES. Earthbound, for the record, is my favorite video game of all time. It is **** (The Best Game Ever Made). Much of what makes Earthbound for me is encapsulated solely in my life. Beating the game at roughly 4 AM, holding the controller, sweating what I can only recall as profusely (the last battle is intense on a psychological level, especially for an eight or nine year old me), I can look at the moment and say that it may be my life, captured in one frame. Is that an incredibly lame, nerdy thing to say? Probably. What is Cave Story, to me, in terms of my life? For all I've tried to say about it, and for all I've tried to avoid the subject in the fear of saying too much, or in the fear of saying it wrong...rambling for the sake of it, because like I said, "reviewing" a game is too cliché. Explaining an experience is so much more rewarding. As I sit on Facebook, and it tells me to get in touch with friends by "sending them a message", despite the fact I know that specific friend doesn't even use the account, I'm left with a feeling that I should maybe send that message. Adulthood is learning that you may not be able to stay friends with everyone. Adulthood is learning to use the time you have to try and keep your friends. Adulthood is those mild inconveniences and those choices which may spread further than you understand.

Cave Story is not adulthood, it is everything you wanted in your childhood. Perplexing and accessible, engaging and exciting. And to sum it all up:

Cave Story is..."well, it's carefully devised art."

Thanks for reading.

1.08.2010

super short post

Bayonetta is a really awesome game (so far). I'm willing to give it the benefit of the doubt right now and assume it'll continue to kick ass and take names until its very end. It is a super stylish affair with fun, but not mindless, game mechanics. It's really not trying to do anything new, but it is so good at what it does. A full length review will likely be following in the coming weeks.

1.02.2010

Metal Gear Solid 4 (**1/2)

A video game “review”

Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriot

developed by Kojima Productions

published by Konami

score: **1/2 out of ****

I used to refer to myself as a fan of video games with somewhat of a disturbing trust in my hobby. They were, essentially, what I enjoyed doing more than anything else. Now, years removed from an outright obsession with them, Hideo Kojima's Metal Gear Solid 4 has come and gone; finally I received the chance to play it. I'm left with a lurking apprehension to call it something I actually enjoyed, despite the relatively high score awarded to it. There were moments within it where the world faded away so that I could bask in the glow of possibly some of the greatest moments of any video game, ever.

Everyone who is anyone remembers Metal Gear Solid, and how it made us feel. It was a cinematic experience and though we barely understood it (and most of us probably still don't), we felt a connection to it, whether or not our enthusiasm for the game came from us actually doing anything, or whether it was us sitting around, watching as a type of magic unfolded on the screen. It was called a masterpiece and launched Kojima into the forefront of video game design. He was at that moment, for all intents and purposes, the man. Unfortunately, he couldn't shake the heavy burden which the game had left for him, it attached itself to him like a leech and here we are, he has released three more numbered Metal Gear Solid games, as well as others. The “story” of the series has expanded beyond any logical measure. All we need to do is look at Metal Gear Solid 4 to understand that there is such a thing as “too big”.

This game, to me, seems to be a cry for help from Hideo Kojima. Solid Snake, the once young protagonist, has become an old man. Despite this, he is carrying his burden. Metal Gear as a series is the burden that Kojima has carried since Metal Gear Solid was released. He has said that he wants to stop making Metal Gear games, yet they keep coming out with him at the helm. This game, his opus according to many, shows off the technical prowess of the PS3 (although I can't understand, especially with mandatory pre-act installations, where the load times could possibly be coming from) but it is not so much a video game as much as it is an “anti-video game”, just as much as it is “anti-literature”.

It is certainly wild of me to use such terms at my leisure, especially since I don't feel qualified to even be writing this review in the first place. There are people who actually get paid for this! The first term, the “anti-video game” can be observed by two simple things:

  1. the excess amount of cut scenes in the game
  2. what these cut scenes accomplish

Metal Gear Solid 4 is a game about its story, as illogical as that may be. The two concepts are attached at the hip so tightly that they likely can't escape from each other without permanent damage. We can play the game with skipping its cut scenes, or we can watch all of them. It's really a decision left up to the player, but even when we know what we're doing, even when we've watched a cut scene a handful of times, skipping it just feels...wrong. The amount of work that went into designing some of the scenes can feel greater than the care that went into several video games themselves. Shouldn't we credit the hard work of those tasked with creating this scenes by you know, actually watching them? Even when they mean nothing in the grand scheme (75% or more of them I'd like to think, do not whatsoever).

The most awe-inspiring moments of the game happen within cut scenes, many of which are so grandiose that we as a player feel a sense of longing to be able to stop saying: “God, I wish I could be playing that!” Raiden, the main character from Metal Gear Solid 2, likely the series' most hated character, returns in this game as a chronic bad ass in cyborg flavor, wielding a katana the way most people only imagine themselves in fiercer than fierce dreams. Never, and I mean this, unfortunately do we ever get to play as Raiden. We can only watch as he accomplishes the greatest feats of illogical choreography we've ever seen. For fuck sakes, we never actually interact with him outside the cut scenes! It's possible, maybe, that Raiden does not exist in Metal Gear Solid 4: The Game and that he is just a figment of Metal Gear Solid 4: The Movie. He is an integral part of the “story”, but he is not even a factor in the game.

I'm not going to sit around and call the plot of this video game stupid or anything like that, because it's just not worth the effort. Maybe it's just too complicated for me to really understand or maybe it's just really poorly written. Characters can and will stumble through dialogue that has no bearing on anything, fictional or otherwise. The wisest statements of the game are simply reworded versions of a simple epithet: “war is bad”. Thanks for the newsflash, Hideo! We may have grandparents that perished during a war, so I think we're allowed to render that opinion ourselves. In this current age, it's a possibility that someone close to you is serving in the Middle East, where death is more than just a fear; it's an outright fact. I feel kind of bad that a game is trying to help me come to that conclusion.

Whenever a video game gets released with the kind of hype and furor that this one received, it's pretty much a given that the personal taste of all professional reviewers goes right out the damned window like an empty bottle on a lingering road trip. It's not hard to point out that really, when it comes to the popular opinion, that we as a species give the public what they expect. People were so caught up with this game that to call it anything than a goddamn masterpiece was editorial suicide, and gamers attacked the least positive of reviews (which still ranged usually between 9 to 9.5 on a scale of 10!) without even playing the game themselves. These are the exact same people who were upset that yes, there were going to be copious cut scenes in this game, and yes, they were going to be long. What exactly were they expecting? Surely, they'd played the previous Metal Gear Solid games. This is nothing out of the ordinary, and thankfully this game lets us pause the movie sequences. People expect weird things.

What did I mean when I called this game “anti-literature”? Not exactly the most well yielded term, although I'll let you in on a bit of a secret; the ambiguity of the term is mostly intentional. Can a video game be literature? Has there ever been a video game worthy enough of that title?

I don't feel that a video game can, or should be literature at all. I think Kojima understood this when he was making Metal Gear Solid 2, in which he attempted suicide  (not his own, but the suicide of his series) by using the game as a platform for a very well executed joke. The people were so in love with Solid Snake after Metal Gear Solid that they wanted more, so Kojima, sick of people clamoring for Metal Gear Solid once more, did several things antagonistic in nature. First off, he faked the death of Solid Snake, and second, he pushed Raiden into his place, who was everything Snake was not. Man, did he ever do a good job of pissing people off, until some people finally understood that it was just a joke. The reaction to this realization baffles me. These gamers who moaned about Raiden suddenly acted like they were in on the joke with Kojima the whole time and took to calling Metal Gear Solid 2 a work of art. Weirder still, people finally came to terms with the postmodernism of the game and acted like they were never angry in the first place. Kojima had told the entire gaming populace a story that could only be told by a video game. That was the first really notable example that a video game shouldn't be literature, instead it simply used its own medium creatively and cunningly to be something truly unique.

Metal Gear Solid 4 is that idea, replicated a million times, over and over, never giving you room to breathe. It is, in fact, shoving that idea down your throat, so forget about breathing room, that's simply not in its directive. Never will this game try not to be lingering outside the fourth wall, and often times; you'll likely laugh at just how weird this can be. Two characters talking about the game console you're playing on itself, like they're aware of the fact that they are video game characters isn't really postmodern as much as it is fucking obnoxious. There's being clever, and then there is trying way too hard. You can likely guess which one of those stuff like that is.

In the second act of the game, we begin to question what kind of video game that Kojima Productions was trying to make when we are thrust out of trying to be stealthy to being testosterone unleaded, wielding a big gun and shooting the fuck out of everything that moves or looks the least bit threatening. By finishing that sequence, which me and my roommate dubbed as “pretty awesome”, you get the ability to watch our good buddy Raiden tear up several nigh-unstoppable enemies (before you start abusing the weapon buying system to obtain heavy artillery) armed with a katana and pretty fucking ridiculously action hero theatrics. As far as rewarding the player goes, I actually think that's pretty good, especially since we did get to do a fun on-rails shooter sequence in a stealth game for no reason other than because it's cool. So cool that a chapter later, we get another rail shooting sequence. And the chapter after that, we get a third on rails section where we play as the big mecha from the first Metal Gear Solid. No, I'm not joking about that either. I think Kojima could make a damn fine rail shooter, perhaps something to rival the genius that was Rez.

Somewhere in the chaotic mess of all this, we start to realize that we have been provided some stuff in the game that nobody really wanted. Part of the tension of a stealth game comes in the fact that we may not be properly equipped at all times. We're given every option to make sure Snake is a walking killing machine. I understand, the shop run by Drebin is the connection to the game's plot point of the war economy, but god damn is it totally unnecessary. All drama is taken out of many moments in the game when you can just open up your menu, in the middle of a damned boss fight, and pay a guy to send you bullets for your best gun. How exactly does Drebin give us our new weapons and ammunition , especially since his service is instantaneous. If he's behind us at all times, why doesn't he just help us? He comes out in Act 2 and quite flagrantly does it (the “pretty awesome” sequence described earlier), so why can't he just do that all the time? Ironically enough, I put this shop system to use quite often, despite my disagreeing with it, because why the hell not?

The largest failing of Metal Gear Solid 4,  is that it simply doesn't try hard enough to be anything more than another one of Kojima's jokes. Now, I realize I've been totally negative through the majority of the review so far, and I apologize for that. I still gave the game a fairly positive score, and the positives do outweigh the negatives as far as I would let on. For the record; it's one of the most infuriating games I've played in recent times and I recall yelling at my television several times, however, none of that was when I was actually playing the game. The frustration only came in trying to be part of the game's experience.

Remember in Metal Gear Solid 2, Raiden faced off against a character named Vamp, who was for whatever reason, immortal? By the end of that game, we had no reason to believe that Vamp was anything other than supernatural. Raiden, the player character, however, could die, at least in the context of playing the game. He could “die”, we would get a game over, we would continue onwards regardless, because it wasn't really Raiden that had died. Nothing had died, no, we had just failed. Failure is one of the biggest aspects of video games, because we have to learn how and why we failed and how to prevent it the next time. The only bigger aspect is that of success. Anyways, back to Vamp. Turns out, his so called immortality was just mundane and poorly explained. In a series where we have fought a psychic, whose claim to possessing the powers was to interact with the player by verifiable actions occurring in real life (you know when Mantis vibrated your controller in Metal Gear Solid, you thought it was all kinds of awesome); it turns out that the concept of immortality is too out there. The oldest game chronologically in the series features a man of advanced age whose body is capable of photosynthesis. That, and he's the father of modern sniping. This, apparently, was normal enough for Kojima when he produced Metal Gear Solid 3.

The final boss battle in this game is actually a pretty awesome fighting game, and it's basically just two tough as nails guys going at it for no other reason than male pride. You've already completed your final objective, by all rights, the game should be over, but we need to settle it, so we do. The weirdest part of this is that in one of the last parts of the multiple cut scenes that make up the way too long ending, we basically get told that we weren't even fighting who we thought we were. In fact, that character had been long dead, even though in...man it's not even worth the explanation. All it did for me, upon hearing it, was confirm that all we had just played was certainly a gigantic joke from Hideo Kojima, attempting once more to self-destruct his own series.

If he was really serious about this, maybe he'd try to hit us where it would really hurt us, in the game as a game, not the game as a story. Super Mario Bros had what was basically no story. There was a missing princess. Go rescue her. Why? Well, because she's not here. Where is she? Well, you're facing right, just keep going that way. No hero starts out in the wrong direction, because that would just be goddamn dumb. Shigeru Miyamoto did more with that basic premise than Hideo Kojima did with all the script of Metal Gear Solid 4. I'm not saying a game can't have a large, complicated narrative and not be good, but I've definitely seen many cases of video game stories where less certainly is more. That's not particularly the point. What I'm saying is that next time Kojima wants to pull a fast one on us, he should make a game that's crappy. It would be a lot easier to create a bad game than it would be to create a shoddily written one, in my opinion. Hell, he could attempt to do both. Beat Takeshi, the famous Japanese comedian, made a video game for the Famicom called Takeshi no Chosenjou (how I've wanted to reference that game for what feels like forever) and he claimed to “hate video games”. Given what the game puts the player through, it's certainly not a stretch of the imagination. It is notoriously difficult, to the point where the focus of its design becomes a flaw since realistically, the game is nigh unplayable and completely unrewarding. If you want to learn more about it, Google is your friend.

Hideo Kojima needs to make a video game that isn't Metal Gear, for his own sake. It's beyond evident at this point that the general gaming public will love anything related to the series, I think it's time Kojima tackled something else before he becomes convinced he can do no wrong. Here's an idea, just a little food for thought. Let him make a game with as convoluted a plot as Metal Gear, but make the game either “bad” or “not Metal Gear”. Make it both, just to see if people start realizing that the plot is actually pretty damn bad. Let him create a game that is nothing more than his way of telling people to go and fuck themselves.

Keita Takahashi, the creator of the pretty much modern art video game Katamari Damacy, was smart enough to back out of making games for the series because frankly, he grew sick of it. He was roped into it by Namco, despite his protests that repeatedly making Katamari games would kill anything unique about it. He was one hundred percent right in that statement. The greatest part about Katamari Damacy, other than the fact that it was unique in every aspect of its presentation, was the fact that its game design was so very simple. It would be my right as a gamer to call Katamari Damacy Keita Takahashi's Super Mario Bros., or even his Tetris (two examples of very simple games that transcend the aforementioned simplicity to be the absolute best examples of this, our hobby). Not everyone gets lucky enough, or is naturally affluent in the task of video game design to create something like that. Shigeru Miyamoto has proven himself possibly the best video game designer of all time; he has come up with classic ideas time and time again, always looking to tread new ground in particularly intriguing ways. Did you know the idea of Pikmin fostered from Miyamoto's passion for vegetable gardening?

What I'd like to see in the near future, from any game designer willing to rise to the challenge, is something wholesome and simple once again. Boldly, I'd love to see someone tackle their “Super Mario Bros.” and abandon the concept of the complicated narrative, leaving us with a story that can be told simply through the context of the game and what we are doing in it. Super Mario Galaxy, a game which I fear to say I do not enjoy, was halfway towards doing something similar to that before it became bogged down by trying to tell us...something. Was it honestly necessary for the game to use dialogue to convey that Bowser had A) kidnapped the princess and B) had some big, evil scheme. I'd really like to see something new come along and take us by storm. As I see promises for more Call of Duty and Guitar Hero games in 2010, I start to worry that I'm asking too much.

Metal Gear Solid 4, is the bee's knees when it actually comes to sitting down and playing it! I'm being one hundred and fifty percent serious when I say it's really fun. I don't really tire of the sneaking, especially since you can approach it several ways and usually have a blast with it. The sections of the game where Kojima tries something radically different are usually pretty fun too. Like I said, the dude could probably cobble together a bitching rail shooter.

Super Mario Bros. 3, which came out a tad before my time (born in 1990 here, people) is exactly what I want from a video game. By expanding on the design of its predecessors, and just adding more, as well as being polished from top to bottom, it took the simple design of the first two games (the second being what we happen to have referred to as the Lost Levels over on this continent) and cranked it up to eleven. Conceptually, Metal Gear Solid 4 is a lot like the other three games, and the focus is still on stealth, which they play quite well in the war zone settings. In some parts, attacking the right enemy group while being near the opposite group will get you recognized by that second group that you're on their side. It's a pretty neat mechanic even though it is rather bare bones in its execution. Unless I was doing it horribly wrong, all it really did was stop them from firing at you. The battles that happened between these two sides seemed to play out the same regardless of whether you made Side B your “guys”.

There's really a thousand little details I could go on and nitpick about, but any writer worth their weight should have a general idea when enough is enough. Fondly looking back at Metal Gear Solid 2 (let's call it ***1/2), I wonder where that boldness went. This game feels so playful in its attempts to break the fourth wall, like it's trying to get a laugh out of you. It tries really hard to be a certain degree of clever, and eventually uses that power for frustration. The exchange between Snake and Otacon about disk changing and the PS3's advanced power is so beyond the fourth wall that it's pretty much a commercial for the PS3. You may wonder why you are being told the advantages of the system when you're already sitting on your couch, playing it. You may chuckle, or you may just sigh, or you may not even do anything at all.

Does anyone remember the fake Game Over screen from Metal Gear Solid 2? In an attempt to royally mess with the player, the game screen becomes significantly reduced and placed inside a Game Over screen. Only, you're still playing the game. Your first time through the game, when you completely were not expecting that, it was something else. All of a sudden, you stop thinking about the game and try to analyze how it was you died. You realize, maybe slowly or perhaps suddenly, that you're still in control. This is when you figured it out; Metal Gear Solid 2 was a video game that could only be a video game. The issue is that Metal Gear Solid 4: The Game doesn't need to be a video game, or more correctly; it can't be just  a video game. Metal Gear Solid 4 only exists as a fusion of it as a game and it as a movie or a “story”. It's just a damn shame that the second concept of the experience had to be so damn flawed, because it really could have been so much more. Thanks for the ride, Hideo Kojima.